A Museum, Library, & Exhibit Gallery
The Old Mystic History Center (formerly the Indian and Colonial Research Center) is a non-profit organization founded in 1965 to preserve the historical research of Eva Lutz Butler.
She was a woman who was passionate about history at a time when a woman's place was NOT leading archaeological digs, conducting anthropological interviews, or writing academic articles.
Are you passionate about history too? Our special research collections will help you find your roots and learn about your history.
In addition, we have accurate information for academic researchers, educators, archaeologists, students, and others to help you add to your story. We are a museum, library, and exhibit gallery located in the historic 1856 Mystic Bank building on Route 27 in Old Mystic, Connecticut.
OMHC ANNUAL MEMBERSHIP MEETING
The Old Mystic History Center held its Annual Membership Meeting and Luncheon at The Steak Loft Restaurant on November 14th.
More than 30 members attended, along with representatives from the Essex Historical Society, Preston Historical Society, and the Society of Founders of Norwich.
Following a brief business meeting, during which the 2026 Secretary’s Report and Treasurer’s Report were presented, members enjoyed a buffet luncheon.
After everyone had settled in, our guest speaker, Tom Hogan, gave an interesting and informative presentation. His topic was, “The Christmas Cartel.” Tom Hogan is a former National Guard officer and retired probation supervisor with a passion for historical research.
“In the first weeks of January 1777, dozens of haggard young men were seen trudging along Connecticut’s rural roadways. They were soldiers from the Continental Army who had been captured by the British months earlier during the battles around New York City. After surviving the grueling conditions in the city’s military jails, 225 had been released and sent to Milford aboard a flag-of-truce ship known in the era as a “cartel.” They were emaciated and worn, and many were infected with the deadly smallpox virus. In his presentation, Tom discussed the plight of these returning prisoners, with an emphasis on those who came from Southeastern Connecticut. Among these was Lieutenant Oliver Babcock of Stonington, who kept a diary of his journey home.”
Old Mystic History Center Annual Secretary’s Report 2026
Welcome to the 59th Old Mystic History Center Annual Membership Meeting and Luncheon. This Year, 2026, marks the 61st year since our incorporation as the Indian and Colonial Research Center in 1965. The Old Mystic History Center continues to retain the name Indian and Colonial Research Center as an authorized member of the Connecticut Genealogical Society.
Our weekly operating hours were Tuesdays and Thursdays, from 10 a.m. to 4 p.m. We also welcomed visitors by appointment, particularly those interested in research.
In 2026, we hosted over 120 visitors, an increase from last year’s attendance of 100. Some came with specific research goals, while others visited out of curiosity. Our guests traveled from across Connecticut and beyond, including states such as New York, Massachusetts, Virginia, Maryland, Texas, California, New Jersey, and Rhode Island. Within Connecticut, visitors came from Stonington, Mystic, Old Mystic, Waterford, Westerly, Wethersfield, Plainfield, Fairfield, Lebanon, Rocky Hill, Groton, New London, Noank, Hamden, Ledyard, Preston. Other visitors came from as far away as Wales and the Czech Republic.
The Old Mystic History Center continues to maintain both a website and an active Facebook page. Our Facebook page currently has 1,200 friends and 1,300 followers. While most of our followers are from the United States, we also have international friends from the United Kingdom, the Netherlands, Germany, Canada, Japan, and India.
Membership support remains our primary source of income. We currently have 105 paid members, with membership renewals still coming in. It is estimated that we will have 120 plus when all renewals are received.
Memory Bank/Old Mystic Oral History Project:
This year we interviewed Gary Wiles, resident of Mystic who was a friend of Kirby Congdon of Old Mystic. Congdon was a well-known author and poet of the Beat Generation. Bob Mohr manned the video equipment, and Paul Grant- Costa directed volunteers who helped to transcribe the audio. Project volunteers have been transcribing the interviews and have been asked to create vignettes to be added to the website for public viewing.These may be added to various exhibits at the Center that focus on people, places and events. There is also a plan to add this data to an interactive map. More interviews are in progress.
Newsletter:
Our Newsletter, published quarterly, is currently being edited by volunteer Christopher Gabianelli. It continues to bring articles of interest about Old Mystic, news about the OMHC interactions with the public, as well as announcements for upcoming events to our members.
Collections Activity:
Some of our new acquisitions this year include papers from the Gallup house, old newspaper clippings on various topics, and Burrow’s family genealogy and letters. Bob Burnside donated excerpts from his father-in-law, Cecil Duerr’s diary. Duerr was born around 1915 and grew up in Mystic and was a “supernumerary” for the town. Books, photos and projectile points were among items donated.
Volunteers, along with the Board, continue to catch up with our inventories. Our extensive scrapbook collection continues to be entered into the database, as are our notebooks. Several donated books
pertaining to Old Mystic, local history, and indigenous topics have been added to the research library.
Work is still being done on the Welch and Marotte collections to prepare them for entry into our database.
Grants:
This year we were awarded grants from the Mystic Woman’s Club, Charles B. Allen Foundation and the Smale / Butler Charitable Foundation. The David Butler and Ruby Smale Charitable Foundation has been donating regularly to the OMHC. The foundation supports organizations that their parents or grandparents founded, especially Eva L. Butler,
Public Outreach:
In May, Board members and volunteers staffed a table at the Alliance for the Mystic River Watershed's Spring Waterfest at Coogan Farm, engaging with attendees and sharing information about our organization. We participated again this September for the Alliance’s Fall Waterfest on Long Pond. On June 13, we welcomed several visitors during Connecticut Open House Day. Guests enjoyed guided tours of our facility and had the opportunity to meet and speak with Board members.
This year, we had the pleasure of speaking with the Daughters of the American Revolution at the historic Fort Griswold Battlefield State Park, as well as presenting programs at Mystic Masonicare and the Pawcatuck Neighborhood Center’s Senior Lunch & Learn. We also enjoyed attending the Old Mystic United Methodist Church Open House celebrating the church’s 200th anniversary.
Miscellaneous:
Plan for a Community Picnic: We have been exploring the possibility of reviving the Old Mystic Community Picnic
Volunteers:
Volunteers have logged over 1000 hours this year, working at the Center and remotely. Our dedicated volunteers work diligently, not only to help visitors with research, but they also answer phone inquiries, catalogue items in our collections, work on data entry, assist in bookkeeping and regulatory filings, write articles for, and distribute our quarterly newsletter, and administer our website and Facebook page, they also help maintain the building and the grounds.
Student volunteers gain valuable experience and knowledge while strengthening their academic
resumés. Volunteering with OMHC is a mutually beneficial opportunity—students develop practical skills, and OMHC benefits from their enthusiasm and contributions. Student volunteers have been transcribing interviews for the Old Mystic Memory Bank/Oral History Project. Alexa Dixon and Stevie Thomson, both students at Connecticut College along with Morgan Casey, have been assisting Paul Grant- Costa with this project. This year’s student volunteers include Patrick Strout. Pat is currently in his senior year at Eastern State University. This is his fourth year with the OMHC.
Maintenance:
Routine upkeep continued this year. We replaced our oil tank, and the railings at our front entrance
were repaired and reinstalled. Professional cleaners spent a day getting into the hard-to-get areas of the Center.
- OMHC Goals for 2026:
Create new exhibits, - Increase fundraising efforts to ensure OMHC remains a viable and stable organization,Increase outreach opportunities for the community,
- Continue to upgrade our website to promote the OMHC and its research possibilities,
- Keep moving forward with our Memory Bank Oral History project,
Recruit volunteer interns from local colleges, - Continue to grow our membership base.
- Find more space to house our growing collections.
These continuing initiatives will help us to carry out the mission of the OMHC and reach a wideraudience.
Board member Cora Grunwald has retired and we would like to thank her for her service and contributions to the Old Mystic History Center, not only as a Board member, but as a volunteer. Thank you, Cora.
Board of Directors
Paul Grant-Costa
George Crouse
Richard Guidebeck
Sharon Maynard
Bob Mohr
Deb Keehn
John Goodrich
Volunteers
Marcus Maronn
Steven Chapman
Patrick Strout
Alexis Coughlin
Lily Dorsa
Christopher Gabianelli
Mary Skousen
Jessica Maynard
Respectfully submitted,
Sharon I. Maynard
Secretary and Acting President
Memory Bank: Call For Home Video Recordings
Help Us Preserve Old Mystic’s Story — Do You Have Home Videos to Share?
Our community’s history isn’t only found in books and archives—it lives in the everyday moments captured by the people who have called Old Mystic home. As part of our ongoing Oral History Project, we are working to collect, preserve, and share these personal glimpses into the past.
We are reaching out to ask for your help.
Do you have any old home video recordings that might include scenes from Old Mystic? We’re especially interested in footage that shows community events, local businesses, neighborhoods, traditions, or simply day-to-day life from years past. Even brief or informal clips can provide valuable insight into how our community has grown and changed over time.
Whether your recordings are on VHS tapes, camcorder cassettes, DVDs, or digital files, we would love the opportunity to review and preserve them. Our team can work with you to safely digitize older formats and ensure your materials are handled with care. Contributors will be fully credited, and we are happy to discuss any preferences you may have regarding how your footage is used.
By sharing your recordings, you are helping us build a richer, more personal record of Old Mystic’s history—one that future generations will be able to see and connect with.
If you think you might have something to contribute, or if you’d like to learn more, please contact us at 860-536-9771 or omhc06372@yahoo.com.
Thank you for helping us keep Old Mystic’s story alive!
Learn more about Old Mystic history. Follow our Facebook page.
Continuing the Legacy
For more than thirty years, members of the Indian & Colonial Research Center's Board of Directors have discussed updating the identity of the Center.
In January 2020, after a two-year deliberative process, the Board made the decision to rebrand the “Indian & Colonial Research Center” with the “Old Mystic History Center” to reflect the growth in our collections. Over the past 50 years, our archival collection has expanded to include many fine manuscripts, publications, photographs, and physical objects connected to the rich and varied history of our area.
While Indigenous and colonial materials are still a large part of our collection’s strengths, our responsibility as the governing board is to care for and promote all the items under our stewardship. We need our research center to maintain relevance, visibility, and viability in the changing world of the 21st Century. The change in our name attempts to address these issues in a realistic community-centered way.




